≡ Menu

The Essential Gingerbread House Candy List

From Mrs. WSL:

I’ve been making gingerbread houses for the holiday season for the past ten years. It’s something that I plan all year long, anticipating the marathon push of decorating my gingerbread house sometime in late October.  I leave it up on display until mid-January and then unceremoniously dump it into the garbage can.  Then I start planning the house for the next year.

When people ask me about making their own gingerbread houses, this is a simple list of essential ingredients I pass along.

An easy gingerbread recipe

You need to have a no-fail gingerbread recipe. I love this one.

Frosting for Gingerbread houses.

It has to be royal icing.  There’s no substitute.  Royal icing is not hard to make. Check out this tutorial.

Candy for Gingerbread housesSee the M&Ms, starlight mints, and gumdrops!

My favorite gingerbread house candy is the starlight mint.  You can’t go wrong with that adorable red and white swirly candy.  It looks cute on a roof, made into a fence, piled up to make a column, or stationed as a wheel on a train.  I can’t think of another candy that says Christmas like the starlight mint.  Watch for them at the store and compare before you buy. There are cheap brands that don’t look nearly as good. I was surprised to find the most precisely swirled candy I found was in the bulk area of my supermarket. They were available all year long. They were vastly superior to the bag that was on the Christmas candy aisle. Oh, and the most important thing about starlight mints—they last forever.  You can use the same bag of mints year after year after year.  I think they could survive in a bomb shelter or something.  I try to buy them during after the season sales to use for the next year.

Next, you need some gumdrops.  These, sadly enough, are not great to save from year to year unless you don’t intend to eat your house, in which case, they can be used when the center has turned cementy. I love to use them on roofs, to line the base of a house, and glued onto sugar cones to make a whimsical tree.   You can glue a gum drop to the wide base of a rolo chocolate then pipe green icing over the gumdrop, and voila!  You have a gumdrop topiary.  They also make great streetlights, bird houses, and large ones can be the perfect base for holding up a sign or a tree.

Red and Green M&Ms usually make it into my gingerbread scene.  They make an adorable roof.  I’ve used the mini multi-colored ones (find them on the baking aisle with the chocolate chips) along the seams of my roof to look like colored lights, too.  I mostly have the M&Ms around to snack on while I do the rest of the decorating.

Finally, having an assortment of nonpareils is essential. Today, you can find these tiny sugary decorations in amazing shapes. I’ve used snowflakes, hearts (buy these in bulk—they are adorable in a Christmas display), gingerbread men, red, green, and white balls, candy canes, and even mini lights. I like to use the nonpareils as decorations on my frosting trees.

Next year, I’m making a house in a blue, silver, and white theme. I am watching out for blue candy all year long in preparation.  Do you have a favorite gingerbread candy?

Comments on this entry are closed.

  • Jessica November 10, 2011, 7:57 pm

    Hi there, i am going to be making a gingerbread house of the market that i work at, which is a restored barn. I am driving myself crazy trying to decide what candy to use for the outside. i am trying to make it look kind of realistic and the tin roof really has me stumped. any suggestions on a grey/silver candy i might be able to use? HELP

    • Josh Hanagarne November 10, 2011, 9:56 pm

      Janette here, if the house doesn’t need to be edible, there’s a great product out there called “highlighter”. It’s a powder that when mixed with extract (vanilla, almond, or lemon) turns in to silver “paint”. Here’s a link: https://www.ckproducts.com/productdetails.asp?getresults=9315 It’s really easy to use. You can also use silver dragees, but they’re expensive to buy and round shaped, so maybe not really realistic.

      I bought my highlighter at a cake shop in town, but you can order online, too. I just finished making a roof out of sour belts candy, which is like strips of fruit leather. It turned out great, but was time consuming to make into shingles. It could work for your roof, as it comes in many colors. I bought mine from the bulk candies at Sunflower market.

      I am launching a new website, planetgingerbread.com that will show the house I completed this year and lots of pics from the past 5 years or so. Hopefully you’ll see some things there to inspire you, too.

      good luck. I’d love to see a picture when you’re done!