Book Review: Winter’s Bone

by Josh Hanagarne on November 7, 2010

winters boneThe Ozarks community in Daniel Woodrell’s novel Winter’s Bone is not quite as chipper as the one from Where The Red Fern Grows. But wow, what a book. I hadn’t heard of this until everyone started fussing about the raves that the movie adaptation was getting up at the Sundance Festival this year, but it is completely deserved. I can’t believe I have never heard of this author before. Woodrell has already written a handful of books, which I will now be tracking down as soon as I get back to work tomorrow morning.

Plot summary of Winter’s Bone

Ree Dolly is 17 years old and lives in a small house in the Ozarks. Her mother has officially lost her marbles, although it’s never revealed exactly what is wrong with her. There is one scene where Ree says “This is exactly the kind of stuff that drove her crazy.” But there aren’t many more clues besides the brutal realities of their lives. Ree is the oldest of four children and is the only one keeping the family alive.

Mom is incapacitated and her father is missing. The fact that he is missing is what propels the book into motion. Ree receives a visit from a police officer who tells her that her father put their family home up for his bond. He was released a week earlier and has now vanished. If he does not come to his trial next week, the family will lose their home. That sounds terrible enough, but being homeless in the place described in Winter’s Bone sounds even worse. I actually watched the film last night after reading the entire book in the morning, and I have to agree with a description Roger Ebert provided in his review:

She treks through a landscape scarcely less ruined than the one in Cormac McCarthy’s “The Road.”

If you have seen or read The Road, that sentence probably makes you shiver a little. It does me.

After the visit from the police officer, Ree goes to find her father. She has to. And that is essentially what happens in the book–she goes from one associate or relative to the next and asks if they know where he is. With each visit and new character that is introduced, we learn a little more about the world Ree lives in. The family is clannish and everyone seems related to each other. This blood-relation, however diluted, is what prompts her suspicious relatives to speak to her, but is also what discourages them from talking to her about her father, for reasons that aren’t clear until late in the story.

The production and selling of illegal substances seem to be the primary industry of the entire place. Her father was mixed up in this, willingly, as most of the novel’s characters seem to be. I can’t talk about her search any more without getting into spoiler territory.

Aside from her hunt, the novel has several scenes of her caring for her siblings and her mother. She teaches them to hunt and skin squirrels, gives them boxing lessons as well as the moral codes for when it is appropriate to fight, and fulfills the duties a capable mother should be doing. Her dream of leaving town and joining the army becomes less likely with every page.

The writing

I’m a William Faulkner fan, but find a lot of his writing unnecessarily convoluted. I would say that Winter’s Bone evokes a mood similar to my favorite Faulkner books with their emphasis on rural Gothic and the  but is nearly impossible to misunderstand or misinterpret. The language is spare but lovely. Mood. Mood is the word that keeps coming back to me. For better or worse, every single paragraph and sentence here feel the same to me. They all convey the same feeling. There are no unnecessary details, but this does not make the world more vague for it. I think the lack of embellishments and flowery language is a mirror of the lives that the people in this place are living, but now I’m starting to venture back into my English major mode, and I’m going to quit.

In a second.

One of the things that keeps echoing in my head is the role of women in this book. I am friends with a local author named Lynn Kilpatrick, and although she will probably argue with me, some of the stories in her wonderful book In The House remind me of scenes and emotions from Winter’s Bone. The potential horrors and prisons of domesticity are amplified a zillion times in Woodrel’s novel, but trapped is trapped. Still, the women in Winter’s Bone are trapped by their situations in what seems like the worst possible way to me, but I’m a man and I don’t live in the Ozarks, so who knows? I did wonder how close to reality it was, regardless. When you read the scenes between Ree and her closest friend, this will make more sense.

I loved this book. I absolutely loved it. It is everything great fiction should be. That’s my Winter’s Bone book summary with everything else pared away. And the movie was fantastic as well. Highly recommended, and please check out Lynn’s work as well.

Josh

Strength Training for body and mind

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

Rox November 8, 2010 at 9:32 am

I’m ordering this book right now. I don’t know if I can
get through it though…sometimes books like this are just too horrific, they are hard for me to read. Josh, have you ever
read “The Long Walk”? It’s by Slavomir Rawicz. It makes me so hungry!

Reply

Josh Hanagarne November 8, 2010 at 10:02 am

Your dad actually recommended that book to me. +1 on hungry.

Reply

rox November 8, 2010 at 11:49 am

I should have known that!
Do you think the story is true?
Do you believe in the Yeti?

Reply

Heather November 8, 2010 at 10:05 am

Will order on payday! Will also scout for the Kindle version, because since I’ve downloaded it onto my PC, I’m getting all lazy and space-saving-crazy n’ stuff. Rockin’ review! Southern Hillbilly Gothic! I loves it!

Heather–who really is a hillbilly, and is betting every scene in that book is just as sparse, true, and painful as the landscape in West Virginia, Kentucky, and parts of Southern Ohio and Pennsylvania.

Reply

Heather November 8, 2010 at 10:11 am

Oh squee! Squee! SQUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!! BOTH available on Amazon, BOTH available as Kindle downloads! SQUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ::jumps up and down, clapping hands like a giant toddler, thus making Max both embarrassed and proud simultaneously::

Reply

Josh Hanagarne November 8, 2010 at 10:59 am

Good grief, Heather. When are you going to give me a guest post written like that?

Reply

Blaine Moore November 8, 2010 at 11:07 am

I haven’t read the book, but I saw the movie on opening night. A friend of mine was the sound engineer. He said it was especially fun trying to figure out what chainsawing an arm off a body that’s underwater should sound like, and then producing that sound. :)

Reply

Big Will November 9, 2010 at 6:40 am

Wow. Rural gothic, The Road, and a little girl’s journey all mentioned in the same review. Thanks Josh. This is in the cue.

Have you reviewed any of Flannery O’Connors work here on your site?

Best,
W

Reply

Josh Hanagarne November 10, 2010 at 2:09 pm

Will, I know I touched about her short story the artificial N***r on here once, but can’t remember where. She’s one of my favorites.

Reply

someone May 16, 2011 at 2:25 pm

Just read the book. I really don’t understand the fuss about the it. In my opinion it was a poorly written book and seemed at times as if it was written by an amateur.

Reply

Steve August 13, 2011 at 10:21 pm

I’m a policeman in Springfield, which is 30 miles north of Forsyth, where the movie was filmed and the screenplay set. This movie accurately reflects the rural meth based life style ever present in this area.

Reply

Josh Hanagarne August 14, 2011 at 8:46 pm

Thanks Steve. I have been very curious about that.

How about the police presence? Was it accurately portrayed? In the book, and in the movie, law enforcement felt peripheral to me.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: